My votes go to the Ashley, Reason behind Roca did not win anything other than one Federation Cup. Ashley Established the club from scratch and won Major team in every season during his stay with BFC.
@7negi True, but Roca's BFC looks more formidable the Westwood. Of course Roca had the platform to build upon, but I will still reckon Roca as better coach.
under ROCA we had very bad I-League but ISL season was great.
Ashley won trophies, ROCA game play was awesome but still I doubt about his subs tactics. May be couple more ISL season we would had difference. Keeping in the mind, ROCA had many good overseas players unlike Ashley need to work with only 4 non Indian players. Hence Ashley was good compared to ROCA.
Lets Bring in Ashley again and see , how he will do in ISL.
Better bring someone more influential and effective then Roca and Ashley. If we want to challenge along side the best clubs in asia then we definitly need an upgrade.
Roca could attract better overseas players than Westwood, agreed Ashley won the i-league but Roca winning 2 cups and almost winning ISL and reaching AFC final is no mean task.
Roca has a better grasp of tactics than Ashley and is less theatrical than the feuding Ashley.
Comments
Ashley or Roca?
My votes go to the Ashley, Reason behind Roca did not win anything other than one Federation Cup. Ashley Established the club from scratch and won Major team in every season during his stay with BFC.
Ashley won trophies, ROCA game play was awesome but still I doubt about his subs tactics. May be couple more ISL season we would had difference. Keeping in the mind, ROCA had many good overseas players unlike Ashley need to work with only 4 non Indian players. Hence Ashley was good compared to ROCA.
Lets Bring in Ashley again and see , how he will do in ISL.
Roca has a better grasp of tactics than Ashley and is less theatrical than the feuding Ashley.