Tax Revenue of state or center is not only inter-dependent on each other but on other states also. It is not that straightforward that one state generated Tax Revenue based on consumption within that State only. New Tax regime of GST will change scenario further with taking it to point of consumption from manufacturing. It will take some years for new system to settle down. Every state contributes in one form or other. Somebody from Gujarat purchase a Car or Electronics made in Tamil Nadu with parts made in Andhra. Jharkhand supply Coal for Thermal Electric plant in Rajasthan or somebody in kerala purchase fuel from a company whose Head office is in Maharashtra-everybody contributes to wherever that Tax revenue is counted.
If people become separate on the basis of Tax revenue, they will lose that source of Raw materials or market/consumption of revenue also and their economy will take a hit.
Hmm. That's interesting. In book my show, the taxes of the State GST goes to the consumer location like kerala instead of maharashtra in which the BMS head office is located. So if a person based in kerala purchase car from maruti suzuki which is based in Haryana, the taxes don't get credit to Haryana state government. Am I correct?
There is no pure race in India. as per research done on Indian DNA shows Indians have mix of Aryan, Dravidian, Mongolian and ,Aborigines race. with people of north India having more Aryan genes, south with more Dravidian and NE with more Mongolian then there are also Negroid race in India, modern day Indians are not of any particular race but a product of mix up many races and tribes for thousands of years.
@indian_gooner Partly true but states will be compensated with 50% share of central excise and service tax for loss of losing revenue of manufacturing plus some more credits.
Not only that there so many issues which government hardly cares
E.g. Fisherman Issue in Tamil Nadu There is no help for fisherman their things are looted or destroyed they are shot down by Sri Lankan navy and our government current and previous hardly take any measures because they don't want to spoil relationships with Sri Lanka
Many such controversies only lead to such talks about DravidaNadu
South Indians are very patriotic but they respect their own culture and tradition to
Comments
If people become separate on the basis of Tax revenue, they will lose that source of Raw materials or market/consumption of revenue also and their economy will take a hit.
A good link
https://www.quora.com/How-will-gst-reduce-the-revenue-for-manufacturing-states
So if a person based in kerala purchase car from maruti suzuki which is based in Haryana, the taxes don't get credit to Haryana state government.
Am I correct?
If the central government who cannot get more votes than Nota here get pissed
And make stupid allegations try foul play
And their propaganda channels always try to show us in the bad light you'll end up making the people angry
Also the four South Indian states contribute more to GDP than all other those north states and get only 0.44 Paisa benefit per 1 rupee
At time of independence, UP was a state that had lot of resources but failed to capitalize because of decades of misgovernance.
Population based sharing of resources should be stopped. Why should we contribute more so that UP folk can reproduce more?
E.g. Fisherman Issue in Tamil Nadu
There is no help for fisherman their things are looted or destroyed they are shot down by Sri Lankan navy and our government current and previous hardly take any measures because they don't want to spoil relationships with Sri Lanka
Many such controversies only lead to such talks about DravidaNadu
South Indians are very patriotic but they respect their own culture and tradition to