i think AIFF should protest the red card and apply for a rematch. Its not the first time. Earlier also in 2006 WC qualifying the uzbekistan and bahrain game was replayed due to an error by referee. Here is the FIFA report about the incident
"
FIFA confirmed today that the result of the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany qualifying match between Uzbekistan and Bahrain on 3 September 2005 has been declared invalid and must be replayed. In order to respect the drawn order of the matches, the first leg is to be replayed in Uzbekistan on 8 October 2005, with the second leg match to be rescheduled for 12 October 2005 in Bahrain.
The decision was taken by the Bureau of the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany Organising Committee following a formal protest from the Uzbekistan Football Federation concerning a technical error by the referee of the match.
According to Art. 12.4 (b) and 14.1 of the Regulations for the 2006 FIFA World Cup, all protests, including those against technical errors committed by referees, are to be decided by the Organising Committee for the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany. A bureau of the Organising Committee may pass a decision in lieu of the plenary committee in urgent matters.
The Bureau, composed of Chairman Lennart Johansson, Deputy Chairman Julio Grondona, Dr Chung Mong Joon and FIFA General Secretary Urs Linsi, took the decision based on the following facts:
1) At the score of 1-0 in favour of Uzbekistan, in the 39th minute of the match, the referee decided to award a penalty kick to Uzbekistan;
2) The penalty kick was taken and led to goal in favour of Uzbekistan;
3) Before the penalty kick was carried out, an Uzbek player entered the penalty area;
4) Consequently, the referee awarded an indirect free kick to the Bahrain team;
5) However, in such a situation, the Laws of the Game require the referee to order the penalty kick to be retaken;
6) The captain of Uzbekistan team protested to the referee immediately after the mistake had taken place and before the game had restarted. This protest was confirmed after the match;
7) This technical error was confirmed by the match commissioner and the referee inspector in their respective reports;
8) Uzbekistan protested the decision of the referee in a written request, asking for the match to be "cancelled" and be evaluated with a 3-0 forfeit result;
The bureau, taking into consideration that the referee in the match in question had indeed committed a technical error, established that, as a consequence, the match needed to be replayed. As a result, the protest put forward by the Uzbekistan team for the match to be considered a forfeit with a 30 result is rejected. In accordance with Art. 12.6 of the Regulations 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany, this decision is final and binding.
"
Will AIFF have time to do this instead of sleeping???
i think AIFF should protest the red card and apply for a rematch. Its not the first time. Earlier also in 2006 WC qualifying the uzbekistan and bahrain game was replayed due to an error by referee. Here is the FIFA report about the incident
"
FIFA confirmed today that the result of the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany qualifying match between Uzbekistan and Bahrain on 3 September 2005 has been declared invalid and must be replayed. In order to respect the drawn order of the matches, the first leg is to be replayed in Uzbekistan on 8 October 2005, with the second leg match to be rescheduled for 12 October 2005 in Bahrain.
The decision was taken by the Bureau of the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany Organising Committee following a formal protest from the Uzbekistan Football Federation concerning a technical error by the referee of the match.
According to Art. 12.4 (b) and 14.1 of the Regulations for the 2006 FIFA World Cup, all protests, including those against technical errors committed by referees, are to be decided by the Organising Committee for the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany. A bureau of the Organising Committee may pass a decision in lieu of the plenary committee in urgent matters.
The Bureau, composed of Chairman Lennart Johansson, Deputy Chairman Julio Grondona, Dr Chung Mong Joon and FIFA General Secretary Urs Linsi, took the decision based on the following facts:
1) At the score of 1-0 in favour of Uzbekistan, in the 39th minute of the match, the referee decided to award a penalty kick to Uzbekistan;
2) The penalty kick was taken and led to goal in favour of Uzbekistan;
3) Before the penalty kick was carried out, an Uzbek player entered the penalty area;
4) Consequently, the referee awarded an indirect free kick to the Bahrain team;
5) However, in such a situation, the Laws of the Game require the referee to order the penalty kick to be retaken;
6) The captain of Uzbekistan team protested to the referee immediately after the mistake had taken place and before the game had restarted. This protest was confirmed after the match;
7) This technical error was confirmed by the match commissioner and the referee inspector in their respective reports;
8) Uzbekistan protested the decision of the referee in a written request, asking for the match to be "cancelled" and be evaluated with a 3-0 forfeit result;
The bureau, taking into consideration that the referee in the match in question had indeed committed a technical error, established that, as a consequence, the match needed to be replayed. As a result, the protest put forward by the Uzbekistan team for the match to be considered a forfeit with a 30 result is rejected. In accordance with Art. 12.6 of the Regulations 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany, this decision is final and binding.
"
Will AIFF have time to do this instead of sleeping???
Hello admin, can we forward it to AIFF? Any one in this forum have contacts with AIFF, please do forward this.
i think AIFF should protest the red card and apply for a rematch. Its not the first time. Earlier also in 2006 WC qualifying the uzbekistan and bahrain game was replayed due to an error by referee. Here is the FIFA report about the incident
"
FIFA confirmed today that the result of the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany qualifying match between Uzbekistan and Bahrain on 3 September 2005 has been declared invalid and must be replayed. In order to respect the drawn order of the matches, the first leg is to be replayed in Uzbekistan on 8 October 2005, with the second leg match to be rescheduled for 12 October 2005 in Bahrain.
The decision was taken by the Bureau of the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany Organising Committee following a formal protest from the Uzbekistan Football Federation concerning a technical error by the referee of the match.
According to Art. 12.4 (b) and 14.1 of the Regulations for the 2006 FIFA World Cup, all protests, including those against technical errors committed by referees, are to be decided by the Organising Committee for the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany. A bureau of the Organising Committee may pass a decision in lieu of the plenary committee in urgent matters.
The Bureau, composed of Chairman Lennart Johansson, Deputy Chairman Julio Grondona, Dr Chung Mong Joon and FIFA General Secretary Urs Linsi, took the decision based on the following facts:
1) At the score of 1-0 in favour of Uzbekistan, in the 39th minute of the match, the referee decided to award a penalty kick to Uzbekistan;
2) The penalty kick was taken and led to goal in favour of Uzbekistan;
3) Before the penalty kick was carried out, an Uzbek player entered the penalty area;
4) Consequently, the referee awarded an indirect free kick to the Bahrain team;
5) However, in such a situation, the Laws of the Game require the referee to order the penalty kick to be retaken;
6) The captain of Uzbekistan team protested to the referee immediately after the mistake had taken place and before the game had restarted. This protest was confirmed after the match;
7) This technical error was confirmed by the match commissioner and the referee inspector in their respective reports;
8) Uzbekistan protested the decision of the referee in a written request, asking for the match to be "cancelled" and be evaluated with a 3-0 forfeit result;
The bureau, taking into consideration that the referee in the match in question had indeed committed a technical error, established that, as a consequence, the match needed to be replayed. As a result, the protest put forward by the Uzbekistan team for the match to be considered a forfeit with a 30 result is rejected. In accordance with Art. 12.6 of the Regulations 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany, this decision is final and binding.
"
Will AIFF have time to do this instead of sleeping???
Hello admin, can we forward it to AIFF? Any one in this forum have contacts with AIFF, please do forward this.
Well, this conversation is circulating in different networks now and most people know about this, AIFF must be knowing this. Many fans claim to have written to AFC and AIFF...so the ball is in their court now
<!-- m --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.the-afc.com/en/abou">http://www.the-afc.com/en/abou</a><!-- m -->t-afc/contact-afc
Urgent- the link given above is the contact of AFC,we had a chat with AFC ,we forwaded them the video of the incident which happened yesterday during INDIA vs UAE,and AFC are disapointed with the REFREEING plus they have promised us a REMATCH ,now go to the above link,please lodge a complain against the refreeing along with the videos . last day of submision is today.
http://www.the-afc.com/en/about-afc/contact-afc
Urgent- the link given above is the contact of AFC,we had a chat with AFC ,we forwaded them the video of the incident which happened yesterday during INDIA vs UAE,and AFC are disapointed with the REFREEING plus they have promised us a REMATCH ,now go to the above link,please lodge a complain against the refreeing along with the videos . last day of submision is today.
I didn't but our Indian football legacy friends (on Facebook) did via the phone. I m just re posting and spreading the news so admin i urge u to start spreading it as well and lodge the protest.
when our moth** fkcning aiff is not interested in lodging a protest what can we do <!-- s:angry-screaming: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/angry/screaming.gif" alt=":angry-screaming:" title="Screaming" /><!-- s:angry-screaming: -->
for a decision regarding a rematch there has to be a formal protest by aiff.
BTW i have also written to them and pasted the vdo link of subrata's red card
the game should be played in fair way......fifa/afc had given qatari a chance to take revenge on the team which defeated his home team.......now let a lebenon ref be given a chance in similar way.....we can guarentee you a better result than 3-0.... <!-- s:violence-smack: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/violence/smack.gif" alt=":violence-smack:" title="Smack" /><!-- s:violence-smack: -->
Comments
Will AIFF have time to do this instead of sleeping???
Hello admin, can we forward it to AIFF? Any one in this forum have contacts with AIFF, please do forward this.
[flash=640,510]http://www.youtube.com/v/SUZ0R_jKkb0?version=3&hl=en_US[/flash]
Well, this conversation is circulating in different networks now and most people know about this, AIFF must be knowing this. Many fans claim to have written to AFC and AIFF...so the ball is in their court now
Urgent- the link given above is the contact of AFC,we had a chat with AFC ,we forwaded them the video of the incident which happened yesterday during INDIA vs UAE,and AFC are disapointed with the REFREEING plus they have promised us a REMATCH ,now go to the above link,please lodge a complain against the refreeing along with the videos . last day of submision is today.
You chatted? How? Where?
for a decision regarding a rematch there has to be a formal protest by aiff.
BTW i have also written to them and pasted the vdo link of subrata's red card