One Nation One League: I-League-ISL Merger

11718202223395

Comments

  • ArsenalFan700ArsenalFan700 Reddit13655 Points
    But we would probably go for the type of guys who have stayed in the past in the longer I-League... guys like Akram or Narjian... guys who honestly would not look completely out of place in the ISL. There are also plenty of players in South America, Africa, and even Asia who are just as good as many foreigners currently in the ISL who would stay in India for a full season and on decent wages.

    As for the bench, well, players do get injured during the season and sometimes a coach may want to switch things around.
  • DXDX 4074 Points
    Having lesser number of foriegners doesnt mean all of them are specialists. Some of our indian players are better than some of them.

    Also having 5 max in a squad means we have to sacrifice quality.
    We aint a top 50 country yet to say we dont need them.
    atuljg
  • @DX You dont get my point.You are talking about quality but tying it up with quantity..10 foreigners on a budget of 15 crores is 1.5 crore on average..You wont get Bernard Mendy for a full season
    Also 5 foreigners is not a drop in quality..Most clubs will play an Indian GK..So there will be 5 Indian players in outfield..If you look at Chennai,Kerala,Pune & Delhi now they have the same no. of indians in outfield, as these teams play a foreign GK..So where is the drop in quality?
    kartik91kuldeep007
  • BrainFallINDIABrainFallINDIA India7506 Points
    We should stick with 3+1 rule IMO,  keeping the playing time and development of our local players in mind,



  • DXDX 4074 Points
    K so ur saying how many foriegners in a usual season squad of say 20-22?
  • atuljgatuljg Trivandrum3986 Points
    @debarghya89 If a reduction in foreigners is required, what is the difference between current I league and future merged league?
  • BrainFallINDIABrainFallINDIA India7506 Points
    We've had a similar situation when I-league was formed , if you have 5+ foreigners in a squad then obvs they will use the foreigners in the main positions such as striker,no10 etc  and not just that even if when someone gets injured indian strikers will not find chances easy to come by
  • ArsenalFan700ArsenalFan700 Reddit13655 Points
    @atuljg Think about it... its not a hard question to answer.
    debarghya89kuldeep007
  • atuljgatuljg Trivandrum3986 Points
    I want ISL to be run like now atleast till Indian players start matching foreigners. I don't want a decline in quality as it could kill the league.
  • atuljgatuljg Trivandrum3986 Points
    edited November 2015
    And @debarghya89, I expect the salary budget will be around 25 Crores in the case of a 10 team league and not 15 Crores. It's already 20 crores with 8 teams.
Sign In or Register to comment.