One Nation One League: I-League-ISL Merger

16162646667395

Comments

  • CybertronCybertron 402 Points
    edited April 2016
    Goa should sell 50% stake of SCDEGOA to a multinational company if they want money to compete against ISL teams in merged league. Or they can follow Atletico de Kolkata model.
  • sanvedjadhavsanvedjadhav 1096 Points
    My suggestion

    ISL merged league (8 isl teams + 4 top I-league) at the top of hierarchy.

    The remaining I-league teams (5 + 7 more through current 2nd div top teams and few corporate clubs) will be second division.

    The current Second division (Around 14 teams who are regional state league top teams) will be Third tier.

    State leagues(cpl,mpl,gpl,mdfa etc) can form the fourth tier 

    Compulsary 2 teams relegation and promotion rule. No exemptions to ANYONE

    Play reserve/U21 teams of isl in 2nd or 3rd tier to give upcoming players more exposure like in European league system so there is no need to apply the U21 rule which many coaches make a mockery of.

    More suggestions, ideas or changes are welcome  :-)
    deepakcAKBBrainFallINDIANagendrakartik91
  • atuljgatuljg Trivandrum3986 Points
    Relegation is not required at the top level till we reach 20 teams and the 2nd tier is of a comparable financial structure to top tier. Otherwise, Relegation would turn into a death sentence for a top tier team. 
    archakdeepakckartik91souravindia
  • BrainFallINDIABrainFallINDIA India7506 Points
    edited April 2016
     I-league will lose it's official tag , So why not allow PSU clubs to play in it ?
    Those who can fulfill minimum requirements ofcourse
    They could start from the 2nd division 
    atuljgArsenalFan700deepakckartik91Deb_Ban
  • archakarchak 2082 Points
    PSU clubs have to form a separate company which is a thing for AFC and AIFF criteria. For that to happen the PSU clubs need to take permission from the parliament where a decision needs to be made.
    Deb_Ban
  • ArsenalFan700ArsenalFan700 Reddit13655 Points
    True but the I-League would be the "second division" now while ISL is the first division and I assume the division where teams play in Asia. Technically I suspect the full AFC and AIFF criteria would not affect PSU clubs in the lower divisions now so we could allow them in... only problem will be the usual stuff like the crap attendances for example. We could also add ISL B teams in these divisions but that may be rushing things.

    And for cup competitions, just don't allow PSU clubs in them, thus the winner can qualify for Asia.
    red_devilatuljg
  • deepakcdeepakc Mumbai 3416 Points
    Yellow brigade has finally put up a banner naming IMGR ..something even WWB didnt have the balls to do....will share it soon....am pretty sure ten would be instructed not to show it by you know who.
    munna219777AKBgoalkeeparsanvedjadhavkarenesudhakar2050atuljggaffertapeDeb_Ban
  • 7negi7negi India10890 Points
    if some one ask you why I league and I league clubs should be given preference over ISL franchise ? what key points you guys will give to support the argument ? @munna21977  @Deb_Ban @gaffertape @sam @AKB  and others ? 

    atuljg
  • gaffertapegaffertape 13021 Points

    @7negi  i like the way you are trying to get us to do your homework...
    reddevil87red_devildeepakcashindiakartik917negimunna219777Soham_Dearchaknamewtheldand 1 other.
Sign In or Register to comment.