One Nation One League: I-League-ISL Merger

1114115117119120395

Comments

  • DXDX 4074 Points
    Scgoa and salgocar meets all the AFC club licensing criteria?
    red_devilatuljg
  • ArsenalFan700ArsenalFan700 Reddit13655 Points
    Exactly and if I-League clubs can fulfill those than what is stopping ISL teams from doing so as well?
    Deb_BanEastBengalPrideatuljg
  • souravindiasouravindia 3757 Points

    you are forgetting the most important aspect that the current I-League teams have..i.e they were part of the top most league for the last 'n' no of years and have always been fore runners in Indian football..when a new league starts they just cannot be thrown into jeopardy

    this should be enough to put up an initial strong fight. other things against the ISL clubs would then come across

    munna219777deepakcDeb_Ban
  • ArsenalFan700ArsenalFan700 Reddit13655 Points
    We have talked about this before and for gods sake I don't know why it is continuing. The league is what? 20 years old? Only East Bengal and Mohun Bagan have been mainstays in all 20 years and chances are they will probably be allowed in ISL. Clubs like Mumbai, Bengaluru FC, DSK Shivajians, Aizawl, and Shillong Lajong have barely been in the top division for that long, esspecially BFC, DSK, and Aizawl. And dealing with them come the merger will probably not be a hassle.

    Again it just comes down to the Goan clubs: Sporting Goa, Salgaocar, and Dempo.
    red_devilatuljg
  • ArsenalFan700ArsenalFan700 Reddit13655 Points
  • EastBengalPrideEastBengalPride India9305 Points
    I can't believe you keep ignoring Salgaocar's history and investments. Anyways, funny thread this :D
    deepakcsouravindiagaffertapeDeb_Ban
  • ArsenalFan700ArsenalFan700 Reddit13655 Points
    They won the league twice and a few Federation Cup's, mainly before this century. So what? And investments have been made but to what avail? They supposedly had one of the best youth set-ups in the country (although with many Goan members on this forum, the team that holds that distinction changes every few months) but where has it gotten us? What has it produced for Indian football? The club, like other I-League clubs, has kept Indian football stagnated for years now.
    deepakcred_devilsouravindiaatuljg
  • NagendraNagendra Rajahmundry, A.P6833 Points
    ;ArsenalFan700..

    Do you believe that clubs like Salgaocar haven't done anything for Indian football.. 

    Salgaocar FC has given good amount of players in international level including youth teams..

    How can we expect from clubs when there are NO returns...Without these clubs, Indian football would have been dead by now..
    gaffertapeDeb_Ban
  • ArsenalFan700ArsenalFan700 Reddit13655 Points
    I believe Salgaocar have given a lot to Indian football since their foundation. They have esspecially given a lot to Goan football and are part of the reason it is as vibrant as it is today. You can go on and on about what Salgaocar have done for Indian football, and also Dempo.

    And ya, Indian football would be dead by now but you could also say it has been dead for a long time... or at least barely breathing.
    red_devil
  • EastBengalPrideEastBengalPride India9305 Points
    As ISL hasn't contributed anything to NT so far their teams should be banned or made to play at Delhi or Pune league - Arsenalfan700 logic :D
    deepakcDeb_Ban
Sign In or Register to comment.